It is better to conquer yourself than to win a thousand battles, Then the victory is yours. It cannot be taken from you.
Capital Gains Indexation;
i) Capital Gain to be mandatorily calculated as per new provision only i.e. without indexation which implies that for exemption u/s 54/54EC & 54F higher amount needs to be invested
Example!!
Sale of Land on 1st Aug 24 – 4 Cr
Purchase in 2001 – 1 Cr
Indexed Cost – 3.48 Cr
Capital Gain – 3Cr
Tax Calculation
New Prov. – 3Cr @ 12.5% – 37.50 Lacs
Old Prov. – 52 Lacs[4Cr-3.48Cr]@ 20%-10.40 lacs
If only 1 Cr is invested :-
Then 2 Cr (i.e. CG – Investment) shall be taxable as Capital Gain.
Now tax on 2Cr @ 12.5% – 25 Lacs
But shall be restricted to 10.40 Lacs (Old Provision)
Here we can see that Investment of 1Cr is not providing any Tax benefit via Sec 54
If 2Cr is invested, then also no benefit!!
If 2.5 Cr is invested:-
Then 50 Lacs shall be taxable as CG
Tax – 50Lacs@12.5% = 6.25 Lacs
Exemption u/s 54EC will also work in same manner
Now Exemption u/s 54F:-
If net consideration of 4 Cr is invested, then entire capital gain Exempt
If 2 Cr is Invested out of Net Consideration 4 Cr:-
Exempt Capital Gain = 3Cr *2Cr/4Cr = 1.5 Cr
Taxable CG = 1.5 Cr
Tax on 1.5 Cr = 1.5 Cr @ 12.5% = 18.75 Lacs
But the same shall be restricted to 10.40 Lacs (old Prov.)
Hence we can see No Tax benefit even on investing 2 Cr.